September 07, 2001
AFL-CIO Opposing Labor Dept. Nominee
FREE Compensation Market Analysis Report! Find out how much you should be paying to attract and retain the best applicants and employees, with customized information for your industry, location, and job. Get Your Report Now!
For a Limited Time receive a
The AFL-CIO is urging the Senate to defeat the nomination of Eugene Scalia, son of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, as the Labor Department's top lawyer, contending that his views are extreme and hostile to workers.
According to the Associated Press, the AFL-CIO's chief objection is Scalia's criticism of Clinton era ergonomics regulations that Congress killed in the spring. In 1999, he wrote in The Wall Street Journal that the then proposed rule "relies on doubtful evidence that repeatedly has flunked the courts' 'junk science' test."
If confirmed, Scalia would become a top lieutenant to Secretary Elaine Chao, providing advice and guidance on virtually every initiative of the department in areas such as safety and health, minimum wages, and pension security.
AFL-CIO President John Sweeney, in a letter to senators released Thursday, called Scalia "simply the wrong person for the job." A confirmation hearing is set for Sept. 20.
The labor federation has debated for months whether to fight the nomination of Scalia, a Washington, D.C., labor lawyer. Sweeney's letter is the first move in labor's decision to oppose the nomination.
"The president has nominated an individual whose extreme views on key worker protections place him outside the mainstream and make him unsuited to hold this important position," Sweeney said.
Labor Department spokeswoman Sue Hensley called the AFL-CIO's position "disappointing but predictable."
Scalia "is highly qualified and supported by a broad spectrum in the labor law community," she said. "And the AFL-CIO's opposition centers almost entirely on Scalia's position on ergonomics, a rule that a bipartisan majority in Congress rejected as extreme."
"The AFL-CIO did not make the decision to oppose Eugene Scalia's nomination lightly," Sweeney wrote. "We recognize that the president has the authority to nominate individuals who reflect his policy views and that President Bush's policy views differ substantially from ours."
Sen. Edward Kennedy, D-Mass., chairman of the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee that will consider Scalia's nomination, has "serious concerns" about Scalia's views on work place safety, said spokesman Jim Manley.
To view an Associated Press story, click here